Explore the differences between 16mm multiwall polycarbonate and 8.8mm laminated clear glass as roofing materials for canopies, focusing on aspects such as cost, durability, and aesthetic appeal.
Cost Comparison and Initial Installation
When considering the roofing material for your canopy design, it is important to compare the costs and initial installation requirements of 16mm multiwall polycarbonate and 8.8mm laminated clear glass. 16mm multiwall polycarbonate is the more cost-effective option, as it is cheaper due to lower material and installation costs. On the other hand, 8.8mm laminated clear glass is generally more expensive due to the cost of glass itself and the additional structure needed for support.
Durability and Maintenance Requirements
Another important aspect to consider when choosing a roofing material for your canopy is its durability and maintenance requirements. 16mm multiwall polycarbonate is classified as non-fragile and impact-resistant, making it suitable for areas where safety is a concern. It is also easier to clean and maintain due to its lighter weight and flexibility. Simply brushing it with warm soapy water when needed is usually sufficient. On the other hand, 8.8mm laminated clear glass is generally considered fragile. However, the laminated glass offers added safety as it holds together when shattered. Cleaning and maintaining laminated glass require more effort and care due to its heavier weight and potential for scratches.
Safety and Impact Resistance
In terms of safety and impact resistance, 16mm multiwall polycarbonate is highly durable against impacts, making it a suitable choice for canopies. It is classified as non-fragile and impact-resistant. In comparison, 8.8mm laminated clear glass is generally considered fragile. However, laminated glass provides added safety as it holds together when broken, reducing the risk of injury from sharp edges.
Energy Efficiency and UV Protection
Energy efficiency and UV protection are important factors to consider when choosing a roofing material for your canopy. 16mm multiwall polycarbonate offers good thermal insulation due to its multiwall structure, reducing the amount of heat that affects the building. This, in turn, reduces energy consumption and costs required to cool the school. It also provides excellent UV protection, typically blocking over 99% of harmful UV rays. On the other hand, 8.8mm laminated clear glass can block UV rays if coated or treated, but without additional treatment it is less effective than polycarbonate. Additionally, it has less effective thermal insulation compared to multiwall polycarbonate and may require additional treatments for improved energy efficiency.
Aesthetics and Visual Clarity
When it comes to aesthetics and visual clarity, 8.8mm laminated clear glass has an advantage. It offers a high-end, clear view and enhances the overall appearance of the canopy. On the other hand, 16mm multiwall polycarbonate may not provide the same level of visual clarity as glass. However, it offers other advantages such as being lightweight, easy to install, and replace if necessary. It is also highly flexible, allowing it to be easily cut and shaped on-site.
Conclusion
In conclusion, when choosing between 16mm multiwall polycarbonate and 8.8mm laminated clear glass as roofing materials for canopies, it is essential to consider factors such as cost, durability, safety, energy efficiency, and aesthetics. While multiwall polycarbonate may be more cost-effective, durable, and energy efficient, laminated clear glass offers superior visual clarity and aesthetic appeal. Ultimately, the decision will depend on your specific needs and preferences. We encourage you to further research and explore the options available to make an informed choice for your canopy project. Whichever material you choose, ensuring it meets your requirements for safety, durability, and visual appeal will result in a functional and visually stunning canopy structure.
